Press "Enter" to skip to content
Photo by Let's Kick

Tiffany Colasuonno Denied Police Report After E-Scooter Crash

On October 27 at around 12:05 p.m., Tiffany Colasuonno stepped into the crosswalk at Park Avenue and East 78th Street on her way to lunch. Waiting until she had the pedestrian walk signal and oncoming cars had come to a full stop, she began crossing in front of 885 Park Avenue when a man riding a stand-up electric scooter came between the stopped cars before striking my upper left arm.

Everything happened in a matter of seconds. Colasuonno instinctively threw her left arm up as the rider tried too late to stop, absorbing the brunt of the collision.

“He said to me, ‘Are you okay?’ and I said, ‘I’m in pain,’ and then he just took off,” Colasuonno recalled.

Although fleeing the scene of an injury collision is illegal, Colasuonno soon discovered that getting the New York City Police Department to document the hit-and-run would prove nearly impossible.

Tiffany Colasuonno
Photo Courtesy of Tiffany Colasuonno

A Bureaucratic Runaround With 311, 911, and the 19th Precinct

Shaken and in pain, Colasuonno returned to her workplace and initially submitted a report through 311. Shortly after, a police sergeant called her back and instructed her to call 911 instead, assuring her that she could place the call once she got home.

When she called 911 from home, however, the operator told her she had to call from the location where the crash occurred and directed her to the NYPD’s 19th Precinct, which covers the Upper East Side. When Colasuonno called the 19th Precinct directly, she could not get through to anyone regardless of which extension she pressed, and her messages went unreturned.

Following instructions, Colasuonno called 911 again once she was back at work, only to be told that officers would not be coming out to take a report because the rider had fled without giving his name.

“I told them, how many people that would do such a thing are going to stop and share their information?” Colasuonno said. “They were saying, well, they’re not required to have a license plate or insurance, so what do you want us to do? I said, ‘Can I at least have a report?’ And they said, ‘No, we can’t do a report because we don’t know his name. We can’t write an imaginary name on there.’”

Medical Diagnosis and Concerns Over Unreported Incidents

The day after the crash, Colasuonno visited her primary care physician to examine the deep bruising spreading across her entire left arm. Her doctor diagnosed the injury as a hematoma, a severe pooling of blood beneath the tissue that goes well beyond an ordinary bruise.

For Colasuonno, the refusal to take a report raises troubling questions about whether city and state leaders, including Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Governor Kathy Hochul, are discouraging paperwork on street incidents to make crime and safety statistics appear better than they are. She also pointed out the contradiction of local Democratic leaders who campaign on protecting women and marginalized groups while failing to respond when women are hurt on city streets, the city’s political rhetoric rang hollow when she actually needed assistance.

Since the accident, Colasuonno continues experiencing symptoms beyond the injury to her arm, including neck and back-of-head pain, dizziness, lightheadedness, and cognitive difficulties. She has since been diagnosed with post-concussion syndrome.

Tiffany Colasuonno Bruise
Bruise After E- Scooter Crash, Photo Courtesy of Tiffany Colasuonno

Pushing for Stronger E-Scooter Enforcement and Official Documentation

Looking beyond her own recovery, Colasuonno worries about what would happen if a speeding e-scooter struck someone even more vulnerable.

“I’m an adult woman, but what if it was a child crossing, or a teenager, or an elderly woman, or a man in a wheelchair?” Colasuonno said. “I hope that the same laws that drivers have to follow when they drive could apply to those on a scooter, and if they do, be better enforced.”

With the 19th Precinct declining to issue a complaint number, State Senator Steve Chan advised Colasuonno to file a Motorist Crash Accident Report through the New York State Department of Motor Vehicles website so that an official record of the incident exists. Colasuonno noted that the DMV portal is geared toward automobile crashes and confusing for pedestrians struck by e-scooters. She has since submitted the DMV report as advised by Senator Chan

In an effort to clarify standard police procedure for pedestrians injured in non-emergency e-scooter hit-and-runs, The Big Apple Gazette contacted 311 and was directed to follow up with the 19th Precinct directly. Our newsroom is reaching out to the 19th Precinct regarding its reporting protocols and will publish a follow-up article once the precinct responds.

Be First to Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

© 2024 - Present. The Big Apple Gazette. All Rights Reserved.